Dry Bulk Shipping: Preparing for the Bust to come
What shipping market bust to come? We are not even out of the current one, I hear you say. Yet, if we heed the facts from historical shipping markets, the above chart is not strictly correct. Shipping market downcycles are low for far longer than the highs (my unscientific rule of thumb is 3 years good, 8 years bad). Asking dry bulk companies to control their newbuilding strategy does not make sense- yet we see this conclusion repeated again and again. Shipping investors are often mostly gamblers- they bet on market recoveries and buy in advance of some signals of a market correction (even in the cases of false dawns). Often they get it wrong, as almost all dry bulk companies did in 2013. This article will discuss strategies to put into place now and in the coming year or so to prepare for the eventual prolonged bust which will eventually and inevitably come to pass.
If the goal of any dry bulk shipping company is to do everything possible to remain long term profitable they must prepare their defenses for an inevitable downturn. The key strategies to put in place now (before the euphoria of any potential market recovery sets in) are as follows:
Have a proper strategy in place- what markets will you serve and how will you succeed in your plan? Having a few ships in every market segment will ensure you have a stake in every market, but it also shows that you haven’t a clue what you are doing. If you are lucky all markets will be up- if not it could be the reverse and you will be out of business. In my view this is simply unacceptable for a professionally managed business. Recently we have seen shifts in strategy in a few dry bulk companies to narrow their specialisation- in my view this is to be applauded. They now have to dive in and build deep relationships with their chosen customers, build trades and routes that they can be strong in in order to really outperform the market over the long term. They also have to reject customers, trades and routes which do not conform to their strategic choices made. Only by making strategic choices can they know what it is that they are really offering to their customers and markets.
A strong balance sheet is crucial. Shipping is a hugely cyclical business, and this means that a strong balance sheet is absolutely critical during tough times. Shareholders must realise this and not demand too heavy dividends during the good years lest they take too big a risk that the company will not survive the downturn. The lease accounting changes in 2019 will necessitate minimal long term charters (which is always well above spot market levels in any case) on the books.
Keep costs to the bare minimum. This is critical- opex, overheads and average costs of vessels must be kept to a minimum. Owners cannot allow this to be uncontrolled- no matter what other shipping companies are doing they must always be cognisant that a prolonged dry bulk shipping downturn is never far away.
Focus on key relationships. Customers, bankers and other supplier relationships are critical for the long term survival of dry bulk shipping companies. Keeping this strong during the good and bad years will go a long way in surviving the inevitable downturns.
Cash position- cash is king, especially during downturns. Having a large owned fleet provides owners with the comfort that cash costs are generally limited to opex, drydocking and finance costs only. Compare this with dry bulk shipping company with the asset light model- all their time charter in’s require full cash payment every day- their cash reserves will dry up fast without cash injections from shareholders. Bankruptcy is never far away without adequate cash reserves.
Dry bulk shipping companies have to think carefully about risks when taking in time charters- too few and you dont have the scale to have a meaningful relationship with customers. Too many and you are done for when the inevitable downturn comes. Resilience must be built in all staff- expectation of downturns, and a clear strategy to survive it, must become second nature to every aspiring dry bulk shipping executive.