|
News Code
94609
Copied
UK MAIB reports on grounding and flooding of St Apollo
TIN news: The UK MAIB has issued an investigation report on the incident of St Apollo (BA 359) which grounded and flooded in Inninmore Bay, Sound of Mull, Scotland on 24 August 2015.
At approximately 0327 on 24 August 2015, the 17m scallop dredger St Apollo (BA 359) grounded on a rocky shelf at the eastern entrance to the Sound of Mull, Scotland. The vessel was not damaged, but listed on the falling tide. Its skipper and four crew abandoned into a liferaft and were recovered by the Oban all weather lifeboat. St Apollo eventually came to rest on its starboard side in a depth of 5m of water. The vessel was later salvaged but was declared to be a constructive total loss. There were no injuries and no significant pollution.
St Apollo had been entering the Sound of Mull from the south-east on an autopilot controlled heading when, it is reported, the vessel unexpectedly altered towards the north. The wheelhouse watchkeeper immediately alerted the skipper, but the vessel
grounded before he arrived on the bridge.
During the investigation, the cause of the unexpected alteration of course could not be determined. In addition, the absence of comprehensive positional records prevented an accurate reconstruction of St Apollo’s movements. However, it was apparent that the wheelhouse watchkeeper was unable to effectively deal with the change in circumstances so close to navigational dangers.
At approximately 0327 on 24 August 2015, the 17m scallop dredger St Apollo (BA 359) grounded on a rocky shelf at the eastern entrance to the Sound of Mull, Scotland. The vessel was not damaged, but listed on the falling tide. Its skipper and four crew abandoned into a liferaft and were recovered by the Oban all weather lifeboat. St Apollo eventually came to rest on its starboard side in a depth of 5m of water. The vessel was later salvaged but was declared to be a constructive total loss. There were no injuries and no significant pollution.
St Apollo had been entering the Sound of Mull from the south-east on an autopilot controlled heading when, it is reported, the vessel unexpectedly altered towards the north. The wheelhouse watchkeeper immediately alerted the skipper, but the vessel
grounded before he arrived on the bridge.
During the investigation, the cause of the unexpected alteration of course could not be determined. In addition, the absence of comprehensive positional records prevented an accurate reconstruction of St Apollo’s movements. However, it was apparent that the wheelhouse watchkeeper was unable to effectively deal with the change in circumstances so close to navigational dangers.
Conclusions
• St Apollo’s grounding was due to navigational error, equipment malfunction, or both.
• It is likely that St Apollo was already significantly to the north of its planned route when the unexpected swing to starboard was noticed.
• The reactions of the wheelhouse watchkeeper were impaired by insufficient situational awareness, a lack of equipment knowledge and a low state of arousal.
• The wheelhouse watchkeeper was unable to meet the challenges he faced alone and at night in such confined waters.
• The cause of the reported loss of heading control immediately before St Apollo’s grounding could not be determined.
• The skipper’s actions following St Apollo’s grounding were well considered and timely.
• St Apollo’s grounding was due to navigational error, equipment malfunction, or both.
• It is likely that St Apollo was already significantly to the north of its planned route when the unexpected swing to starboard was noticed.
• The reactions of the wheelhouse watchkeeper were impaired by insufficient situational awareness, a lack of equipment knowledge and a low state of arousal.
• The wheelhouse watchkeeper was unable to meet the challenges he faced alone and at night in such confined waters.
• The cause of the reported loss of heading control immediately before St Apollo’s grounding could not be determined.
• The skipper’s actions following St Apollo’s grounding were well considered and timely.
The MAIB has issued a safety flyer to the fishing industry to highlight the advice provided in MGN 313(F).Furthermore, a recommendation has been made to the owner of St Apollo aimed at improving watchkeeping practices and enhancing the safety on any vessel he may own in the future.
Further information may be found by reading the investigation report below
Further information may be found by reading the investigation report below