| News Code 94449
Copied

PPA asked to reject ۳۷.۴۵% increase in cargo handling fees

PPA asked to reject ۳۷.۴۵% increase in cargo handling fees
|
TIN news:   Various port user groups have urged the Philippine Ports Authority (PPA) to reject the petition by Manila North Harbor Port, Inc. (MNHPI) for a 37.45 percent increase in cargo handling tariff warning this would translate into higher cost of goods and services.
MNHPI, operator of Manila North Harbor, had filed a petition before the PPA but various port stakeholders branded the increase “excessive” and “unwarranted.”
Sulficio Tagud Jr., chairman and president of the Philippine Liner Shipping Association (PLSA) in a 13-page position paper warned that the 37.45 percent increase in cargo handling tariff would more or less translate to a 12.37 percent increase in freight rate which the shipping lines will be constrained to pass on to shippers and eventually to be borne by the consumers by way of a proportionate increase in consumer goods and services.
To aid in the review to rationalize the MNHPI petition for a 37.45-percent increase in cargo handling tariff, Tagud said: “It is strongly suggested for MNHPI to submit a cost-benefit or cost-effective analysis of the North harbor development project.”
Tagud has urged the PPA to consider MNHPI a public utility because it provides service mostly to shipping lines, which are considered public utilities.
“Shipping lines docking at North Harbor have no other option but to avail of MNHPI services,” said Tagud.
“As such, the government should not only regulate the MNHPI return on investment and profit margins but also have to make sure that no unnecessary costs are included in the computation because ultimately, the public will pay for the inefficiencies of the operator.”
Sergio Ortiz-Luis, president of Philippine Exporters Confederation (Philexport) believes the increase as not only too much but “unjust and unwarranted.”
Ortiz-Luis explained that domestic trade and port stakeholders have no choice but to transact business with MNHPI. As such, he said, it should even cut its cost rather than increase it.
Ortiz-Luis, who is also the vice chairman of the Export Development Council representing the private sector, has called on the PPA to reject the MNHPI petition, saying it would be prudent for PPA to defer action on the proposed 37.45 percent tariff increase until President Rodrigo Duterte has appointed a full complement of PPA officials.
Using 2014 PPA statistics where volume in 20-foot equivalent unit or TEUs – inbound and outbound Manila – is 1,043,705 with PLSA having 86 percent share on total volume carried at the North Harbor, PLSA executive director Rona Gatdula said the impact of the increase in freight tariff rate would translate to an additional annual stevedoring cost of P118.78 million among PLSA members.
“The MNHPI is enjoying a perceived monopoly status in domestic shipping. It is actually making money. But to pass on to the shipping lines what the MNHPI is claiming that they need more income to remedy their problems on cost drivers would seem unfair to us and in the end, the consumers,” Gatdula said.
In addition to stevedoring, other cargo handling rates, which may eventually be passed on to the shippers were wharfage, cranage, storage, stuffing and shifting, among others, she said.
Ortiz-Luis said MNHPI should defer its petition to demand an increase so as to allow the new administration a free hand in deciding on the issue.
The Philippines Inter-Island Shipping Association (PISA), the umbrella group of domestic shipping and related associations, said the PPA should defer any action “on the MNHPI rate-increase petition until a new board of directors is appointed by President Duterte.”
PISA executive director Pedro Aguilar said it supported PLSA’s position “en toto” in opposing the increase, citing PPA statistics showing a steady increase in volume handled at the North Harbor, which enabled MNHPI to generate net income or total comprehensive income of P177.9 million for 2012, P305.7 million for 2013, and P332.6 million for 2014.
“Percentage-wise, net income to revenue, MNHPI’s net incomes for the said years represents 13 percent, 19 percent and 16 percent, respectively,” Aguilar said.
The PLSA and the Supply Chain Management Association of the Philippines (SCMAP) earlier questioned the upward tariff adjustment predicated on the need for additional investment on equipment and infrastructure that they said would put into question the original basis for the awarding of a franchise to operate a port to a contractor.
“Over the years, there have been tremendous economic changes that adversely affected the business environment in the Philippines. These have affected critical cost drivers necessary to support port operations such as labor, fuel, power and equipment maintenance expenses, among others. All of these have consistently added to the cost to operate Manila North Harbor,” said MNHPI chief executive officer Richard Barclay.
Bloomfuits Banana-Shippers and Consignees Association president Juniorita Pulgo said the cargo handling tariff of 37.45 percent was considered “very high.”
A technical working group composed of PPA officials and government agencies will review the position papers, as well as MNHPI’s reply to these papers, and make a recommendation to the PPA Board, which will make the final decision.
Send Comment