|
News Code
81294
Copied
Court favours terminal operator PSA - Sical over govt - owned port trust
TIN news: A court in Tuticorin, Tamil Nadu, has rejected a petition filed by Union government-owned V. O. Chidambaranar Port Trust (VOCPT) challenging the award of an arbitration tribunal that allowed one of the private container terminals at the port to move to a revenue-share format from a royalty model for the residual period of its 30-year contract that ends in 2028.
The petition has been dismissed, the principal district court, said on its website on Thursday.
The court order would mean that the terminal, a joint venture between Singapore’s PSA International Pte Ltd and local firm Sical Logistics Ltd, will be entitled to re-write the contract citing change in law.
VOCPT is expected to appeal the district court order, a spokesman said. The district court order will set the tone for other similarly affected cargo handlers to seek re-writing of contract terms.
“That’s the larger picture,” said a Mumbai-based port consultant.
“The underlying issue is whether a change in law entitles a concessionaire (terminal operator) to renegotiate the terms of the concession agreement or to rewrite the contract. That is the fundamental issue”.
“Change in law will allow or entitle concessionaires to re-write the agreements,” he said, asking not to be named, citing a conflict of interest because his firm advises VOCPT.
PSA-Sical Terminals Ltd, the entity that runs the container terminal at VOCPT, is 62.5% owned by PSA International, a unit of Temasek Holdings Pte Ltd, Singapore’s state-run investment firm. The balance stake is held by Sical Logistics. The terminal has been dogged by tariff issues for many years.
In June 2011, PSA secured a stay from the district court in Tuticorin, freezing the annual royalty it is contractually mandated to pay VOCPT at the level set for 2010 as part of the 30-year contract.
This was the first instance of a court-backed freeze on revision in royalty for a port contract after the ports sector was opened to private funds in 1997.
According to the terms of the PSA contract, the royalty per container was Rs.102 in the second year of operations. In the 30th year of operations in 2028, it will reach Rs.5,178 per container.
As a result of the Tuticorin district court order, PSA continues to pay a royalty of Rs..1,969 per container (the level set for 2010 in the contract) to VOCPT.
If the stay had not been granted, PSA would have been contractually mandated to pay Rs.2,264 per container as royalty to VOCPT from 15 July 2011.
This would have risen to Rs.2,490 a container from 15 July 2012, going up to Rs.2,615 from 15 July 2013, Rs.2,746 from 15 July 2014, Rs.2,883 from 15 July 2015, and so on.
In the 16 years since starting operations in 1999, PSA made three attempts to raise rates for the services provided at the terminal, but each time the tariff regulator for Union government-controlled ports slashed rates—by 15% in 2002, 54% in 2006 and 34% in 2008, which PSA did not implement, securing stay orders from the Madras high court.
PSA has defended its move to freeze the royalty pay-out with the backing of the court, arguing that the tariff cuts would reduce the revenue-earning capability of the terminal and turn it into a loss-making unit.
PSA has argued that it cannot give more royalty to VOCPT till it is allowed to increase rates.
VOCPT filed an appeal before the Madurai bench of the Madras high court to vacate the stay granted by the district court.
Meanwhile, PSA opted for arbitration while the Madurai bench of the Madras high court was hearing the case.
The arbitration award, passed on 14 February 2014, said that PSA-Sical Terminals should be allowed to move to a revenue-share format from a royalty model by adopting the revenue-share percentage of 55.19% quoted by ABG Container Handling Pvt. Ltd in September 2012 for a new container terminal, the second at Chidambaranar port.
The district court order rejecting the appeal filed by VOCPT confirms the arbitration award, the consultant mentioned earlier said.
The petition has been dismissed, the principal district court, said on its website on Thursday.
The court order would mean that the terminal, a joint venture between Singapore’s PSA International Pte Ltd and local firm Sical Logistics Ltd, will be entitled to re-write the contract citing change in law.
VOCPT is expected to appeal the district court order, a spokesman said. The district court order will set the tone for other similarly affected cargo handlers to seek re-writing of contract terms.
“That’s the larger picture,” said a Mumbai-based port consultant.
“The underlying issue is whether a change in law entitles a concessionaire (terminal operator) to renegotiate the terms of the concession agreement or to rewrite the contract. That is the fundamental issue”.
“Change in law will allow or entitle concessionaires to re-write the agreements,” he said, asking not to be named, citing a conflict of interest because his firm advises VOCPT.
PSA-Sical Terminals Ltd, the entity that runs the container terminal at VOCPT, is 62.5% owned by PSA International, a unit of Temasek Holdings Pte Ltd, Singapore’s state-run investment firm. The balance stake is held by Sical Logistics. The terminal has been dogged by tariff issues for many years.
In June 2011, PSA secured a stay from the district court in Tuticorin, freezing the annual royalty it is contractually mandated to pay VOCPT at the level set for 2010 as part of the 30-year contract.
This was the first instance of a court-backed freeze on revision in royalty for a port contract after the ports sector was opened to private funds in 1997.
According to the terms of the PSA contract, the royalty per container was Rs.102 in the second year of operations. In the 30th year of operations in 2028, it will reach Rs.5,178 per container.
As a result of the Tuticorin district court order, PSA continues to pay a royalty of Rs..1,969 per container (the level set for 2010 in the contract) to VOCPT.
If the stay had not been granted, PSA would have been contractually mandated to pay Rs.2,264 per container as royalty to VOCPT from 15 July 2011.
This would have risen to Rs.2,490 a container from 15 July 2012, going up to Rs.2,615 from 15 July 2013, Rs.2,746 from 15 July 2014, Rs.2,883 from 15 July 2015, and so on.
In the 16 years since starting operations in 1999, PSA made three attempts to raise rates for the services provided at the terminal, but each time the tariff regulator for Union government-controlled ports slashed rates—by 15% in 2002, 54% in 2006 and 34% in 2008, which PSA did not implement, securing stay orders from the Madras high court.
PSA has defended its move to freeze the royalty pay-out with the backing of the court, arguing that the tariff cuts would reduce the revenue-earning capability of the terminal and turn it into a loss-making unit.
PSA has argued that it cannot give more royalty to VOCPT till it is allowed to increase rates.
VOCPT filed an appeal before the Madurai bench of the Madras high court to vacate the stay granted by the district court.
Meanwhile, PSA opted for arbitration while the Madurai bench of the Madras high court was hearing the case.
The arbitration award, passed on 14 February 2014, said that PSA-Sical Terminals should be allowed to move to a revenue-share format from a royalty model by adopting the revenue-share percentage of 55.19% quoted by ABG Container Handling Pvt. Ltd in September 2012 for a new container terminal, the second at Chidambaranar port.
The district court order rejecting the appeal filed by VOCPT confirms the arbitration award, the consultant mentioned earlier said.