| News Code 67734
Copied

Consolidating port assets

Consolidating port assets
|
TIN news:    A new company or a business trust – that’s the question on some investors’ mind as to what MMC Corp Bhd could possibly do with its port operations.
It is no secret that the diversified conglomerate – whose business interests range from automotive to electricity generation and infrastructure – has plans to merge all its port operations under a single umbrella.
Talk of the market in recent months is that the ultimate intention is to eventually list the consolidated port businesses of the group on the local bourse, even as work continues towards strengthening the group’s foothold in the shipping industry.
That plan seems to be gaining momentum now as MMC has made an offer to buy out NCB Holdings Bhd – whose most prized asset is the Northport in Port Klang – and take the latter private.
But observers note MMC may not necessarily adopt the conventional way of listing their port businesses.
There is a possibility of the group looking at an alternative route of spinning off its port assets into a business trust.
A business trust is somewhat like a real estate investment trust, or REIT, as both instruments share some common characteristics – the clearest one of which is both are supposed to generate stable income in the form of regular dividends to investors and both are publicly traded in the equity market.
Structurally, though, business trusts and REITs are different. While REITs are an investment scheme investing in real estate and properties, business trusts operate like a business enterprise, investing in sectors and assets to generate stable income.
Few companies in Malaysia have talked about giving this route a thought in the past. But so far, none has taken the advantage to list their assets as business trust on Bursa Malaysia, although the guidelines for such listing had already been issued by the Securities Commission since December 2012.
Still a relatively new concept for the Malaysian capital market, though, a business trust can afford benefits to corporations and investors alike.
“From the corporate point of view, listing assets as a business trust is ideal in enhancing cash flow, while maintaining control over the assets through a trustee-manager,” an analyst tells StarBizWeek, noting that this could be the main factor driving MMC group to consider this route.
In the region, at least one port operator had gone down this route – Hutchison Whampoa Ltd, which belongs to Hong Kong tycoon Li Ka-shing, listed its container port business as Hutchison Port Holdings Trust on the Singapore Stock Exchange in 2011.
MMC group at present already controls almost all the container maritime terminals in Peninsular Malaysia.
MMC’s largest shareholder Seaport Terminal (Johore) Sdn Bhd fully owns the Penang Port after buying the loss-making seaport from the government at an undisclosed price last year, while MMC itself owns a 100% stake in Johor Port in Pasir Gudang and 70% interests in Port of Tanjung Pelepas (PTP).
End to speculation
And now, ending months of speculation, the diversified conglomerate is well on its way to fully own Northport, which is known as a major gateway for import and export boxes alongside its competitor Westports in Pulau Indah.
This comes after MMC triggered a mandatory general offer (MGO) for NCB.
Over the week, MMC raised its stake in NCB from 30.13% to 83.55% after acquired a total of 53.42% in the port and logistics operator at RM4.40 per share from Permodalan Nasional Bhd and AmanahRaya Trustees Bhd.
In its filings with Bursa Malaysia, MMC had stated that it would extend the offer of RM4.40 per share to minority shareholders of NCB, as it had no intention to maintain the listing status of the latter.
NCB fully owns Northport (M) Bhd, which has 30 years remaining concession tenure to operate and manage the port in Port Klang. NCB also operates a haulage cum logistics business via its subsidiary Kontena Nasional Bhd.
The acquisition of NCB is part of MMC’s strategic initiative to strengthen its core business of ports and logistics.
Gaining control over NCB – an established company in the port industry – is expected to not only boost MMC’s financial position, but will also help maintain the latter’s position as a key player in the Malaysian maritime industry.
But taking NCB private will come with quite a heavy price tag for MMC, according to an analyst.
“The potential privatisation of NCB will not come cheap to MMC,” AffinHwang Capital Research analyst Lim Tee Yang says in his report.
He notes that at RM4.40 per share, MMC is valuing NCB at price-earnings ratio of 55 times based on the annualised 2015 estimated earnings per share of eight sen. In comparison, Lee points out, the shares of Westports Holdings Bhd – another port operator in Port Klang – are currently trading at 26 times its estimated 2015 earnings.
“If the MGO were successful, MMC would acquire the remaining 16.5% in NCB at an additional cost of RM340mil,” Lee says.
Nevertheless, Lee stresses that MMC will still benefit as NCB’s future earnings may improve from rising container throughput and potential container tariff revisions. And strategically, he adds, NCB would increase MMC’s presence in the central region of Peninsular Malaysia.
NCB expects to handle 3.3 million twenty-foot equivalent units (TEUs) this year, compared with around 2.6 million TEUs last year.
Despite lower revenue for the first six months of 2015, NCB saw its net profit more than double to RM18.65mil, or four sen per share, during the period under review, compared with RM7.57mil, or 1.6 sen per share, in the first half of last year.
During the period in review, the group saw its revenue fall 5.2% to RM390.2mil from RM411.4mil previously.
NCB’s earnings growth over the first six months of this year was mainly attributable to lower expenditure and higher contributions from the group’s port operations.
Send Comment