|
News Code
65417
Copied
Gov’t to move forward with port
TIN news: Premier Hon Alden McLPremier Hon Alden McLaughlinaughlin has announced that the Progressives-led government will move on to the next stage of development of the proposed cruise ship berthing facility in George Town Harbour, even though he said no “formal decision” has been taken on the project.
The announcement came during the premier’s speech at the CI Chamber of Commerce Legislative luncheon at the Ritz-Carlton yesterday.
He said the cruise ship berthing facilities are part of the parcel to renew George Town and pose no threat to Seven Mile Beach.
“The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) has indicated while there will be some damage to reef structures in the immediate vicinity, the project will not cause harm to Seven Mile Beach. This was a major concern, and has been put to rest,” said Mr McLaughlin.
Premier McLaughlin said Cabinet is still to make a formal decision and that decision is expected to be announced over the next few weeks.
However, he said, “I can say today that government has considered the matter carefully and has agreed on the merits of building a cruise port and enhanced cargo port and to allow the project to proceed to the next stage.”
The next stage, he explained, “involves discussions with the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, Government and cruise companies which are needed regarding the design of the piers and the structure of the project’s financing.”
The Premier said the public representation from both sides of the debate were considered and that the cruise industry must have their “skin in the game” when it came to the project as they are the ones who bring the cruise ship passengers here.
He said there is no immediate plan of action.
“I hasten to add, there will not be dredges in George Town harbor tomorrow or next week or next month. Instead we will proceed carefully and seek to do whatever it takes to ensure minimum environmental impact,” said the Premier.
“We will take the time necessary to plan and engineer the building of the piers, including planning and logistics, and will look carefully at the mitigation methods,” he added.
The Premier explained that the project would provide hundreds of jobs for Caymanians, and protect Cayman’s Tourism industry well into the future.
“One thing is certain in my mind, economic benefits aside, we continue to anchor cruise ships in George Town Harbour as we have done for these past forty years, in a decade or two there will be very little coral for us to argue about,” he contended.
He declared that the government has been called on by “opponents and proponents, to decide between protecting the environment or protecting the economy. However the Premier explained that after 40 years of building a cruise tourism industry the government is “duty bound” to ensure that business does not move to Cuba or other destinations.
“It cannot be ignored that of the 22 countries in the Caribbean and Central America at which cruise ships currently call, the only one that does not have or is not in the process of building cruise piers is the Cayman Islands. I know some of us are proud of bucking the trend, but I’m not sure this is a trend we should be bucking,” he declared.
The Premier said that there will always be some sacrifice in the name of “future success” before explaining that government would undertake a modern National Development Plan to “help us progress.”
Even as the port debate raging locally, US news organization CNN has covered the development here in an article on its online service.
The article, entitled ‘Grand Cayman’s Reef must not be destroyed’ leaves no illusion as to what side of the port debate its authors are on, with CNN marking a disclaimer that the views expressed are not necessarily those of the organization as a whole.
The report warns of complete destruction of the reefs, referred to as “complex three-dimensional structures that form over thousands of years.”
“There is no reef relocation, transplantation or mitigation that will bring back or restore the natural environmental and economic treasure that will be lost if the unique coral reef resources of George Town harbor are destroyed,” said Ellen Prager, Steven Miller and Carl Safina in their article.
The independent scientists appear to have no apparent financial gain to be made from their input and claim that the Balboa is the number 1 dive site.
John MacKenzie, founder and principal shareholder of West Indian Marine has refuted such arguments. He said the wreck of the Balboa can’t be listed as Cayman’s number one dive site, due to the high traffic in the Harbour area already.
“What they’ve said about it being the number one dive site is simply not true,” said Mr MacKenzie, “You can’t dive in that area on weekdays, only on some weekends or days where there are no cruise tenders or cargo ships.”
Mr MacKenzie explained that the fears over water turbidity due to the cruise ship thrusters were exaggerated due to the computer modeling in the Baird and Associates EIA simulation the thrusters being used unrealistically.
“They had the ship sitting there running at half a head, which is 50% power, three thrusters for fifteen minutes. If a cruise ship captain did that he would be four miles on the way to Cuba, and he’d be carrying a piece of the dock with him,” he said.
Mr MacKenzie noted that the claims had since been retracted.
“It just shows you how people who don’t know, can easily be misled,” he said, adding that the computer modeling did not take into account factors such as the turbidity being trapped under the dock. If you don’t want to believe me, just go down to the dock, and see how they clear the dock by going slow ahead, until they get way out past the designated area,” said Mr MacKenzie.
The announcement came during the premier’s speech at the CI Chamber of Commerce Legislative luncheon at the Ritz-Carlton yesterday.
He said the cruise ship berthing facilities are part of the parcel to renew George Town and pose no threat to Seven Mile Beach.
“The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) has indicated while there will be some damage to reef structures in the immediate vicinity, the project will not cause harm to Seven Mile Beach. This was a major concern, and has been put to rest,” said Mr McLaughlin.
Premier McLaughlin said Cabinet is still to make a formal decision and that decision is expected to be announced over the next few weeks.
However, he said, “I can say today that government has considered the matter carefully and has agreed on the merits of building a cruise port and enhanced cargo port and to allow the project to proceed to the next stage.”
The next stage, he explained, “involves discussions with the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, Government and cruise companies which are needed regarding the design of the piers and the structure of the project’s financing.”
The Premier said the public representation from both sides of the debate were considered and that the cruise industry must have their “skin in the game” when it came to the project as they are the ones who bring the cruise ship passengers here.
He said there is no immediate plan of action.
“I hasten to add, there will not be dredges in George Town harbor tomorrow or next week or next month. Instead we will proceed carefully and seek to do whatever it takes to ensure minimum environmental impact,” said the Premier.
“We will take the time necessary to plan and engineer the building of the piers, including planning and logistics, and will look carefully at the mitigation methods,” he added.
The Premier explained that the project would provide hundreds of jobs for Caymanians, and protect Cayman’s Tourism industry well into the future.
“One thing is certain in my mind, economic benefits aside, we continue to anchor cruise ships in George Town Harbour as we have done for these past forty years, in a decade or two there will be very little coral for us to argue about,” he contended.
He declared that the government has been called on by “opponents and proponents, to decide between protecting the environment or protecting the economy. However the Premier explained that after 40 years of building a cruise tourism industry the government is “duty bound” to ensure that business does not move to Cuba or other destinations.
“It cannot be ignored that of the 22 countries in the Caribbean and Central America at which cruise ships currently call, the only one that does not have or is not in the process of building cruise piers is the Cayman Islands. I know some of us are proud of bucking the trend, but I’m not sure this is a trend we should be bucking,” he declared.
The Premier said that there will always be some sacrifice in the name of “future success” before explaining that government would undertake a modern National Development Plan to “help us progress.”
Even as the port debate raging locally, US news organization CNN has covered the development here in an article on its online service.
The article, entitled ‘Grand Cayman’s Reef must not be destroyed’ leaves no illusion as to what side of the port debate its authors are on, with CNN marking a disclaimer that the views expressed are not necessarily those of the organization as a whole.
The report warns of complete destruction of the reefs, referred to as “complex three-dimensional structures that form over thousands of years.”
“There is no reef relocation, transplantation or mitigation that will bring back or restore the natural environmental and economic treasure that will be lost if the unique coral reef resources of George Town harbor are destroyed,” said Ellen Prager, Steven Miller and Carl Safina in their article.
The independent scientists appear to have no apparent financial gain to be made from their input and claim that the Balboa is the number 1 dive site.
John MacKenzie, founder and principal shareholder of West Indian Marine has refuted such arguments. He said the wreck of the Balboa can’t be listed as Cayman’s number one dive site, due to the high traffic in the Harbour area already.
“What they’ve said about it being the number one dive site is simply not true,” said Mr MacKenzie, “You can’t dive in that area on weekdays, only on some weekends or days where there are no cruise tenders or cargo ships.”
Mr MacKenzie explained that the fears over water turbidity due to the cruise ship thrusters were exaggerated due to the computer modeling in the Baird and Associates EIA simulation the thrusters being used unrealistically.
“They had the ship sitting there running at half a head, which is 50% power, three thrusters for fifteen minutes. If a cruise ship captain did that he would be four miles on the way to Cuba, and he’d be carrying a piece of the dock with him,” he said.
Mr MacKenzie noted that the claims had since been retracted.
“It just shows you how people who don’t know, can easily be misled,” he said, adding that the computer modeling did not take into account factors such as the turbidity being trapped under the dock. If you don’t want to believe me, just go down to the dock, and see how they clear the dock by going slow ahead, until they get way out past the designated area,” said Mr MacKenzie.