| News Code 62635
Copied

The Burman effect on stevedoring

The Burman effect on stevedoring
|
TIN news:        Ramakant Burman is a man vilified by India’s stevedores and shore cargo handling agents after the shipping ministry changed the way permits are sold to the entities that load and unload cargo from the non-mechanized, common user cargo terminals at ports owned by the government.
 
Following a sustained campaign by Burman (he was dismissed from service by Kolkata Port Trust in December 2013 for being a whistleblower), the ministry on 12 August announced that stevedoring and shore handling agent permits will henceforth be sold on the basis of revenue share.
 
The revenue share will be discovered through auction and the ceiling/maximum rates to be collected by stevedores and cargo handling agents from exporters and importers will be fixed by the Tariff Authority for Major Ports (TAMP).
 
Consequently, the highest revenue share price determined through auction will have to be matched by all other eligible stevedores/shore handling agents currently operating in these ports to be allowed to hold permits for work.
 
This will ensure sufficient competition between stevedores and shore handling agents so that the market can decide the rates within the ceiling set by TAMP.
 
Stevedores load and unload cargo to and from ships while shore handling agents undertake carting, storing and delivering the consignment to customers in the case of imports and receiving the cargo, storing, feeding and loading them onto a ship for exports.
 
While the law requires both stevedores and shore handling agents to hold work permits, only the former are licensed after they pay an annual fee and that, too, without a tender. More importantly, their rates are not notified by TAMP. In fact, the previous stevedoring policy of the shipping ministry allowed stevedores to charge rates from customers based on market forces.
 
On average, there are at least 50 licensed stevedores operating in each of the 12 ports, resulting in claims that there was stiff competition among the service providers and lower rates for exporters and importers.
 
After issuing licenses, the port authorities have no role in their functioning as the stevedores and shore handling agents are engaged by exporters and importers based on competitive quotations to load and unload cargo from non-mechanized berths. They are paid by the exporters and importers who hire them but none of this money is shared with the port which has invested in constructing the berths by way of royalty or revenue share, a point that was highlighted by Burman to drive home the point that ports were losing money because of the way permits were sold.
 
A five-member panel of port chairmen that was set up by the ministry to study and make recommendations following the controversy favoured licensing of stevedores and shore handling agents and their rates being set by TAMP.
 
However, the panel was not in favour of issuing permits to these entities on the basis of revenue share, arguing that extracting a revenue share may raise the transaction cost of exporters and importers and lead to diversion of cargo from major ports (those owned by the Union government) to non-major ports (those owned by the states where rates are decided by market forces) that are already growing at almost five times the rates of the major ports.
 
This recommendation has a point. If a truant bidder wants to play spoilsport, he can quote a very high revenue share, which other eligible entities may find exorbitant to match. This could result in only one entity or a very few of them carrying out stevedoring and shore handling, creating a monopoly, instead of the average 50 operating now in each port. In such a scenario, the possibility of cargo diversion to non-major ports would look real. For this reason, stevedores and shore handling agents are dreading the revenue share model for buying permits more than them coming under the ambit of TAMP to set their rates.
 
Burman’s counter-argument to this is that the major ports will be able to win back the cargo lost to non-major ports with TAMP setting rates for stevedoring and shore handling activities that will be much lower than what they are charging customers in a free pricing regime. Extracting a revenue share from these entities, Burman says, will not raise the transaction costs because it is not allowed as a cost element while setting rates, according to government rules.
 
This has been demonstrated at the Haldia Dock Complex of Kolkata Port Trust when it opted for an auction to select shore handling agents on a revenue share basis with ceiling rates set by TAMP. Shore handling agents at Haldia (four of the 146 agents have a market share of 93%) were charging customers between Rs.200 and Rs.250 per tonne of cargo handled for many years without sharing any of this levy with the government-owned Kolkata Port Trust.
 
But, for the auction, TAMP set a ceiling rate of Rs.119.48 per tonne which fetched a highest revenue share price bid of Rs.14.77 per tonne for Kolkata Port Trust. Now, all those looking to get a shore handling agent work permit at Haldia will have to give this revenue share to the port on the cargo volume handled. Out of the 273 million tonnes (mt) of dry bulk cargo handled by the ports owned by the government in 2014-15, half or about 140 mt were handled by stevedores and shore handling agents, with the balance loaded by public-private-partnership operators who, in any case, pay revenue share to government ports discovered through tender.
 
The shipping ministry has, in its wisdom, decided to opt for revenue share to select stevedores and shore handling agents in a bid to earn some money from outsourcing these activities, discipline them and check any scope for cartelization. The new policy has removed the clause on mandatory booking of port labour by these entities even if they are not required, which will help reduce the port logistics costs by lowering the operating costs of stevedores and shore handling agents.
Send Comment