| News Code 62023
Copied

Singapore fines for unlicensed bunker fuel suppliers not severe enough: trade

Singapore fines for unlicensed bunker fuel suppliers not severe enough: trade
|
TIN news:       The fines imposed by the Singapore courts on unlicensed bunker fuel suppliers at the port are not severe enough to deter repeat offenders, according to trade sources.
 
The Maritime and Port Authority this week said that Singapore bunker supplier JL Petroleum had been charged and subsequently pleaded guilty in court on August 18 to supplying bunkers in the Port of Singapore without a valid bunker supplier license issued by MPA.
 
An MPA spokeswoman said this week that “JL Petroleum Pte Ltd was fined a total sum of S$5,000 ($3,567.70) for supplying bunkers in the Port of Singapore without a bunker supplier licence issued by the Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore.”
 
One bunker fuel supplier said: “The sum of S$5,000 is really small, and would not be drastic enough to deter offenders from trying to borrow another supplier’s licence.”
 
While the MPA penalty for suppliers who lend their licenses to unlicensed suppliers is to revoke their licenses, that penalty is more severe for lenders than the fine for borrowers, said several trade sources.
 
“A fine of S$5,000, in comparison with what these borrowers pay to use the license is small. If they are using the license to deliver a 5,000 mt parcel of bunker fuel, the borrower typically pays the lender around a $1-3/mt margin for each tonne they deliver and this could work out to as much as S$15,000 each time they borrow the license,” said one market source.
 
If they are already paying S$15,000 to borrow a licence, a $5,000 fine is nothing in comparison, said trade sources.
 
The profit margins that these borrowers get for flouting the law might well be worth the risk for some, the source added.
 
The Singapore court judges usually decide the sum of the fine to be imposed and “as the fine was determined by the Court, we are unable to comment on it,” MPA told Platts.
 
MPA TIGHTENING ENFORCEMENT
 
Trade sources also noted that while MPA previously only penalize suppliers who lend their licenses for such activities, MPA now appears to be also penalizing the companies borrowing the licenses.
 
The case of JL Petroleum this week is the second such incident of MPA enforcing penalties on the borrower, MPA told Platts.
 
The first such case was on May 26 last year, when MPA took Progressive Power to court. The fine imposed on the company was also S$5,000, said MPA.
 
MPA typically takes into consideration the number of deliveries where use of the bunker supply licence was breached, said market sources familiar with the regulations.
 
In the case of JL Petroleum, it had been found to have supplied bunker fuel on 14 occasions between June 2 and 25, 2013, without a license.
 
Explaining their stricter enforcement efforts, MPA said it takes “serious view of any bunkering malpractice and will not hesitate to take action against any unlicensed entity operating in the Port of Singapore.”
Send Comment