|
News Code
51900
Copied
Nissan Murano, Ford Flex take top spots in IIHS small - overlap test
TIN news: The 2015 Nissan Murano and 2015 Ford Flex earned IIHS top safety picks in the most recent round of small-overlap front crash testing, but other models in the crossover segment continue to fall short of the insurance institute’s standards.
The Murano and the Flex were the top performers in a group of seven 2015 model year midsize SUVs put through the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s small-overlap front crash testing for the first time. The other vehicles were the Jeep Wrangler, Jeep Cherokee, Hyundai Santa Fe, Dodge Durango and Dodge Journey.
The Murano received good ratings in structure and restraints and kinematics and in all four dummy injury measures for an overall good rating and the IIHS’s Top Safety Pick+, the institute’s highest award.
IIHS spokesman Russ Rader said the Murano likely did well in the small-overlap front crash test because Nissan had integrated the test into the development of the redesigned Murano.
“The small overlap test did definitely play a role in the development of the Murano,” said Nissan spokesman Phil Lienert. “Safety was a top concern for the Murano, and it features what we call our ‘safety suite.’”
The Flex earned good ratings in all four dummy injury measures but just an acceptable rating in restraints and kinematics and a marginal rating in structure. These scores earned the Flex an overall acceptable rating and a Top Safety Pick.
The small-overlap test is considered to be exceptionally rigorous because the vehicle’s front-end crush zone is bypassed, making it more difficult for the vehicle to manage the crash energy. Vehicles that fare well in other IIHS crash-test scenarios don’t always meet the same success in the small-overlap front crash test.
“For buyers of midsize SUVs, there is no reason to not buy a vehicle that gets less than good or acceptable ratings in this test,” Rader said.
“This is a newer test based on research that shows this is a scenario not covered by government testing,” he said. “A poor performance doesn’t mean these vehicles are suddenly unsafe.”
Including an earlier group of midsize SUVs that IIHS tested, there are now seven vehicles to choose from in the segment that qualify for IIHS safety awards, Rader said. The other vehicles are the Chevrolet Equinox, GMC Terrain, Kia Sorento, Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander.
In the insurance institute’s small-overlap frontal crash test, 25 percent of the driver’s side front end strikes a barrier at 40 mph. Small-overlap frontal crashes account for about a quarter of all injuries and deaths that occur in frontal crashes, according to IIHS. The test was adopted in 2012.
Fiat Chrysler Automobiles’ Dodge Journey, which received overall good ratings in the moderate overlap front, side, roof strength and head restraints and seats crash tests, received a poor overall rating in the small-overlap front crash test.
The Dodge Durango and Jeep Cherokee also received good ratings in the other four IIHS crash-test scenarios but performed below IIHS standards in the small-overlap front crash test, receiving marginal overall ratings.
FCA spokesman Eric Mayne said the automaker is still confident in the safety of the Journey and the Durango, emphasizing that “no single test” can account for the overall safety of a vehicle.
The Journey, which was introduced in 2008, features a considerably older design than the other vehicles in this round of small-overlap front crash testing.
“What we are noticing is that older designs are doing less well,” Rader said.
The Jeep Wrangler was the only FCA vehicle in this round of small-overlap front crash testing to receive a good overall rating.
The Hyundai Santa Fe received a marginal overall rating.
Since the insurance institute introduced this test in 2012, automakers have responded in two ways, the institute said in a statement. The first is by integrating the test into the development of new models, as with the Nissan Murano, and the second is by making modifications to strengthen the front structure and improve airbags before a model goes through a redesign.
“We know that performance in the small-overlap test boils down to the structure of the vehicle,” Rader said. “As automakers integrate the small overlap into their vehicle testing and development, we expect to see improvements.”
The Murano and the Flex were the top performers in a group of seven 2015 model year midsize SUVs put through the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s small-overlap front crash testing for the first time. The other vehicles were the Jeep Wrangler, Jeep Cherokee, Hyundai Santa Fe, Dodge Durango and Dodge Journey.
The Murano received good ratings in structure and restraints and kinematics and in all four dummy injury measures for an overall good rating and the IIHS’s Top Safety Pick+, the institute’s highest award.
IIHS spokesman Russ Rader said the Murano likely did well in the small-overlap front crash test because Nissan had integrated the test into the development of the redesigned Murano.
“The small overlap test did definitely play a role in the development of the Murano,” said Nissan spokesman Phil Lienert. “Safety was a top concern for the Murano, and it features what we call our ‘safety suite.’”
The Flex earned good ratings in all four dummy injury measures but just an acceptable rating in restraints and kinematics and a marginal rating in structure. These scores earned the Flex an overall acceptable rating and a Top Safety Pick.
The small-overlap test is considered to be exceptionally rigorous because the vehicle’s front-end crush zone is bypassed, making it more difficult for the vehicle to manage the crash energy. Vehicles that fare well in other IIHS crash-test scenarios don’t always meet the same success in the small-overlap front crash test.
“For buyers of midsize SUVs, there is no reason to not buy a vehicle that gets less than good or acceptable ratings in this test,” Rader said.
“This is a newer test based on research that shows this is a scenario not covered by government testing,” he said. “A poor performance doesn’t mean these vehicles are suddenly unsafe.”
Including an earlier group of midsize SUVs that IIHS tested, there are now seven vehicles to choose from in the segment that qualify for IIHS safety awards, Rader said. The other vehicles are the Chevrolet Equinox, GMC Terrain, Kia Sorento, Nissan Pathfinder and Toyota Highlander.
In the insurance institute’s small-overlap frontal crash test, 25 percent of the driver’s side front end strikes a barrier at 40 mph. Small-overlap frontal crashes account for about a quarter of all injuries and deaths that occur in frontal crashes, according to IIHS. The test was adopted in 2012.
Fiat Chrysler Automobiles’ Dodge Journey, which received overall good ratings in the moderate overlap front, side, roof strength and head restraints and seats crash tests, received a poor overall rating in the small-overlap front crash test.
The Dodge Durango and Jeep Cherokee also received good ratings in the other four IIHS crash-test scenarios but performed below IIHS standards in the small-overlap front crash test, receiving marginal overall ratings.
FCA spokesman Eric Mayne said the automaker is still confident in the safety of the Journey and the Durango, emphasizing that “no single test” can account for the overall safety of a vehicle.
The Journey, which was introduced in 2008, features a considerably older design than the other vehicles in this round of small-overlap front crash testing.
“What we are noticing is that older designs are doing less well,” Rader said.
The Jeep Wrangler was the only FCA vehicle in this round of small-overlap front crash testing to receive a good overall rating.
The Hyundai Santa Fe received a marginal overall rating.
Since the insurance institute introduced this test in 2012, automakers have responded in two ways, the institute said in a statement. The first is by integrating the test into the development of new models, as with the Nissan Murano, and the second is by making modifications to strengthen the front structure and improve airbags before a model goes through a redesign.
“We know that performance in the small-overlap test boils down to the structure of the vehicle,” Rader said. “As automakers integrate the small overlap into their vehicle testing and development, we expect to see improvements.”