|
News Code
48154
Copied
India’s shipping market could be out of bounds for global fleet owners
TIN news: India’s shipping market, worth a freight bill of $57 billion annually, could soon be out of bounds for global fleet owners after the government scrapped a key tender condition that tilts the scale in favour of local shipowners. In a public tender, an Indian ship has the so-called right of first refusal to match the lowest rate quoted by a foreign-flag ship and take the contract, according to the rules set by the director general of shipping, India’s maritime regulator, in 2004 to extend cargo support and develop the local shipping industry.
This is subject to the condition that the difference in the bid price between the Indian-flag vessel exercising the right of first refusal and the lowest rate quoted by the foreign flag vessel shall be limited to 10%. The right of first refusal is not available to India-registered ships if the difference in bid price is more than 10%.
The director general of shipping scrapped this requirement last week for tenders to finalize a so-called contract of affreightment (CoA) and channel deepening works at ports using dredgers. A CoA is a long-term contract under which a shipowner agrees to transport a specified quantity of cargo at a specified rate per tonne between the designated loading and discharge ports during a specified period. The change will help local fleet owners get assured business. In the earlier rule, local fleet owners were at risk of losing business if their price quotation did not come in the 10% range of the lowest foreign bid. Now, they can quote any price and still enjoy the privilege of the right of first refusal. The downside of such an arrangement is that global fleet owners will have no incentive to participate in tenders as the process would be rendered meaningless.
Secondly, the rate discovery mechanism—the purpose of all open, competitive bidding—will suffer as local fleet owners could be tempted to indulge in cartelization. Entities looking to hire ships for transporting cargo could possibly end up paying more on ship rentals due to reduced competition. The maritime regulator also said that India’s ship chartering (hiring) guidelines will soon be reviewed in toto, in line with the government’s policy of promoting and strengthening Indian shipping. Indian shipowners have always raised the bogey that the share of India’s external trade carried on India-registered ships has fallen from about 40% in the late 1980s to less than 10%, while clamouring for cargo support from the government. They have only themselves to blame for this situation. Indian shipowners have always preferred deploying their ships in international trades when the market is good to maximize their earnings.
There is nothing wrong in this. But, when the market conditions turn bad, they always look to the government for support, as is the case now with the Baltic Dry Index (BDI), a benchmark for shipping dry bulk commodities, at record-low levels. During such times, Indian shipowners have tended to quote higher rates partly because of the high cost of doing business in India. On the other hand, foreign fleet owners have been able to quote competitive rates because they are not subjected to the slew of taxes that their Indian counterparts pay. India plans to boost its home fleet by an ambitious 400% to 43 million gross tonnage (GT) by 2020 from the current 10. 31 million gross tonnage.
The Narendra Modi government has taken several facilitative measures since coming to power in May 2014 to achieve this target. These include issuing life-time licences to Indian ships to reduce red tape so that they can ply un-interrupted, re-writing the rules for seafarers working on Indian-flag ships to qualify them for non-resident status and allowing Indian shipowners to register ships in overseas tax-friendly jurisdictions without the need to open subsidiaries abroad.
This will enable Indian shipping companies access cheaper sources of funds abroad to acquire additional tonnage (shipping capacity) while not having to set up multiple enterprises abroad to acquire and maintain such tonnage. By altering the terms of exercising the right of first refusal, the government appears to be giving local fleet owners a quid pro quo when demands from container terminal operators for opening up the country’s coastal trade to foreign container shipping lines shipowners are growing.
India’s coastal trade—shipping cargo between local routes—is reserved for India-registered ships and foreign ships can be hired when Indian ships are not available, with the approval of the maritime regulator. Indian shipowners do not own sufficient container ships, unlike other types of ships, and container terminal operators have been urging the government to allow foreign container lines to operate along the coast to ensure that their facilities are fully utilized.
This is subject to the condition that the difference in the bid price between the Indian-flag vessel exercising the right of first refusal and the lowest rate quoted by the foreign flag vessel shall be limited to 10%. The right of first refusal is not available to India-registered ships if the difference in bid price is more than 10%.
The director general of shipping scrapped this requirement last week for tenders to finalize a so-called contract of affreightment (CoA) and channel deepening works at ports using dredgers. A CoA is a long-term contract under which a shipowner agrees to transport a specified quantity of cargo at a specified rate per tonne between the designated loading and discharge ports during a specified period. The change will help local fleet owners get assured business. In the earlier rule, local fleet owners were at risk of losing business if their price quotation did not come in the 10% range of the lowest foreign bid. Now, they can quote any price and still enjoy the privilege of the right of first refusal. The downside of such an arrangement is that global fleet owners will have no incentive to participate in tenders as the process would be rendered meaningless.
Secondly, the rate discovery mechanism—the purpose of all open, competitive bidding—will suffer as local fleet owners could be tempted to indulge in cartelization. Entities looking to hire ships for transporting cargo could possibly end up paying more on ship rentals due to reduced competition. The maritime regulator also said that India’s ship chartering (hiring) guidelines will soon be reviewed in toto, in line with the government’s policy of promoting and strengthening Indian shipping. Indian shipowners have always raised the bogey that the share of India’s external trade carried on India-registered ships has fallen from about 40% in the late 1980s to less than 10%, while clamouring for cargo support from the government. They have only themselves to blame for this situation. Indian shipowners have always preferred deploying their ships in international trades when the market is good to maximize their earnings.
There is nothing wrong in this. But, when the market conditions turn bad, they always look to the government for support, as is the case now with the Baltic Dry Index (BDI), a benchmark for shipping dry bulk commodities, at record-low levels. During such times, Indian shipowners have tended to quote higher rates partly because of the high cost of doing business in India. On the other hand, foreign fleet owners have been able to quote competitive rates because they are not subjected to the slew of taxes that their Indian counterparts pay. India plans to boost its home fleet by an ambitious 400% to 43 million gross tonnage (GT) by 2020 from the current 10. 31 million gross tonnage.
The Narendra Modi government has taken several facilitative measures since coming to power in May 2014 to achieve this target. These include issuing life-time licences to Indian ships to reduce red tape so that they can ply un-interrupted, re-writing the rules for seafarers working on Indian-flag ships to qualify them for non-resident status and allowing Indian shipowners to register ships in overseas tax-friendly jurisdictions without the need to open subsidiaries abroad.
This will enable Indian shipping companies access cheaper sources of funds abroad to acquire additional tonnage (shipping capacity) while not having to set up multiple enterprises abroad to acquire and maintain such tonnage. By altering the terms of exercising the right of first refusal, the government appears to be giving local fleet owners a quid pro quo when demands from container terminal operators for opening up the country’s coastal trade to foreign container shipping lines shipowners are growing.
India’s coastal trade—shipping cargo between local routes—is reserved for India-registered ships and foreign ships can be hired when Indian ships are not available, with the approval of the maritime regulator. Indian shipowners do not own sufficient container ships, unlike other types of ships, and container terminal operators have been urging the government to allow foreign container lines to operate along the coast to ensure that their facilities are fully utilized.