| News Code 48149
Copied

India: Only way out for domestic shipping companies is to pass through it

|
TIN news:         The only way out is through it. The line perhaps aptly describes what the domestic shipping industry is suppose to do as it continues to battle the unusually long trough phase in its business with little light at the end of the tunnel.
 
The grim situation being faced by the industry is also evident from the stock price movement where leading companies such as Shipping Corporation of India, Great Eastern Shipping, Mercator and Varun Shipping among others have been witnessing a fall for quite sometime now.
 
High value assets helping churn low income has been the stubborn situation these companies have been facing since the last seven years–post financial crisis in 2008.
 
“Shipping is cyclical in nature but the current depression is the worst I have seen for this industry,” S Hajara, former chairman and managing director of Shipping Corporation of India with more than 35 years of experience told Business Standard.
 
“What made it worse was that just before the crisis, asset prices were at their peak and companies invested at these levels,” Hajara told Business Standard. Hajara has been ranked among the top 100 influential personalities in the global shipping industry in 2010 by TradeWinds and Lloyd’s List, two well-known industry journals.
 
Shipping Corp, the country’s largest shipping company, has been witnessing heavy losses last three years with its earnings per share staying at nil. Mercator’s standalone business, which is mainly pure shipping, reported a profit only in FY14 after a gap of three years. Both companies have their debt:equity ratio above 1.25 as on March 31, 2014.
 
It is known that dry bulk freight rates are hitting new lows every day, while tanker and container are managing the show for these companies as of now. However, what needs to be known is how these companies plan to keep themselves afloat in the current hand-to-mouth situation and the way ahead for them.
 
“One option is that companies can identify specialised segments for themselves and keep playing in the same area to derive assured revenue for themselves,” Sudarshan Shreenivas, senior analyst with India Ratings said. For instance, state-owned Poompuhar Shipping Corporation runs ships to ferry coal to thermal power stations operated by Tamil Nadu Generation and Distribution Corporation. This gives the shipping company an assured revenue stream though the margin is slim.
 
“Container shipping companies can look for certain fixed trade routes like India-Singapore, India-Thailand which continue to be busy and though with limited scope of operations, there is a sure shot business scope,” said Sreenivas.
 
Scrapping of aged vessels mainly in the bulk segment could also be an option for shipping companies which would not just bring down their fleet maintenance costs but also help pay off some portion of their debt.
 
“We are mulling to scrap our two 30-year old bulk carriers. Though this can help us reduce our debt, it will not bring down the debt very significantly,” said a senior official with Essar Shipping. “We are looking to get it scrapped either in Bangladesh, China or Karachi, whereever we get the best price,” he said without revealing price details. The company’s consolidated debt as on FY14 stands at Rs 5,600 crore.
 
A well-diversified fleet, tightening of costs along with an eye for consolidation could also help companies keep their heads above water, said industry officials.
 
“Fleet exposure to all segments like bulk, container, tanker and offshore can help companies mitigate losses. At the same time, vessels could be well divided between spot and long-term contracts so that the latter can yield assured business no matter how rates moves in the spot,” said Sreenivas of India Ratings.
 
Shipping Corp for instance has a well diversified fleet of 69 vessels with 70 percent tanker exposure, in turn having itself well positioned despite its exposure to the bulk segment via 17 carriers, where currently the problem is acute due to poor freight rates.
 
“The market is such that we are keeping all our options open as of now. We are tightening costs, where it is interest costs or input costs, we are pracitising cost efficiency. Scrapping one of our bulk carriers is also something we are discussing,” said Captain Kowshik Kuchroo, president- Shipping at Mercator. The company has seven tankers, one VLCC and 13 bulk vessels. Mercator’s bulk business is handled by its Singapore subsidiary Mercator Lines (Singapore).
 
However, compared to the global market, domestic shipping companies are in a much better position more so because of their larger exposure to the tanker division compared to the bulk, said experts.
 
“Fortunately, India has lesser exposure to bulk than tanker. Of the entire country’s fleet, around 60 percent exposure is towards tanker and balance 40 percent includes bulk and container. Globally, companies have 90-95 percent exposure to bulk, making their situation more grim,” said Hajara.
 
Most industry officials were of the view, that going ahead bulk is expected to remain sluggish, while container, offshore and tanker may take turns to make up for some of losses from the former.
 
“Dry bulk is a leading indicator of global economic activity and from the prevailing rates it easy to predict that the global economy is not picking up for the next six months atleast. Manufacturing across world is down and so this segment will continue to see low freights,” said Sreenivas of India Ratings. “Atleast for the next two years, the bulk segment is not going anywhere,” said Kuchroo of Mercator.
 
The container segment meanwhile, looks a bit promising since it is oligopolystic in nature. “Around 70-80 percent of the total container market is controlled by few companies globally. Due to this, capacities can be regulated as per requirement and this is what lends support to container freights,” said an industry official on condition of anonymity.
 
Tanker and offshore though look promising as of now, a lot depends on crude oil moves going ahead, said experts.
 
“Onshore exploration has been coming down since quite some time and so offshore exploration will not see slowdown to a great extent even if crude oil prices fall a bit more,” said Sreenivas.
 
“Falling bulk freight is expected to push out private equity players in the segment who had made speculative buys earlier. This will shrink the order book and thereby bring in some discipline in the dry segment,” said Kuchroo of Mercator.
 
Meanwhile, analysts recommend investors to remain invested in companies like Shipping Corp and Great Eastern Shipping that have a well-diversified fleet.
 
“Agreed that sentiment is weak in the shipping sector, but the worst is behind us,” said Vikram Suryavanshi, senior analyst with Antique broking. Alongside, analysts also recommend investors to enter some of the shipping stocks since they are currently trading at a discount to their net asset value.
Send Comment