|
News Code
34120
Copied
DMAIB issues report re the allision of a cargo ship with the Masnedsund Bridge
TIN news: On 13 April 2014, the general cargo ship KARLA C allided with the Masnedsund Bridge causing severe damage to the ship and minor damage to the bridge and railway.
KARLA C was one of ten sister ships within the company and it was tramp trading primarily in Northern Europe and the Mediterranean carrying break bulk and regular bulk such as steel and grain. Neither the ship nor the master had called at the Port of Vordingborg before, but this was not considered a significant challenge, because the ship tended to call at smaller ports of a similar size in channels and rivers that are less accessible for other larger ships.
The Masnedsund Bridge that connects the islands of Zealand and Masnedø was built in 1937, is 215 metres long and has a width of 8.8 metres. It is a combined bascule bridge with a single-track railway and a road. It has five supporting pillars and a height between 4 and 5 metres from the water surface to the spans.
On the seabed on the western side of the bridge where the port is situated there are power cables and pipelines for sewage, gas and district heating.
The bridge is usually manned daily, except during the hours of the night unless otherwise agreed with a ship requesting a scheduled passing. Approximately 2,000 ships of varying sizes pass the bridge annually.
In 2002, a risk analysis was made of the scenarios in which a ship might allide with the bridge pillars and/or the steel structure. The analysis concluded that the bascule supporting pillars should be able to withstand the impact of a ship with a range of displacement of 6,400-7,800 t if the bridge pillars were to be considered as belonging in a high safety class. Furthermore, the steel beams between the pillars should be able to withstand the impact of a ship with a range of displacement of 1,500-4,700 t if the steel beams were to be considered as belonging in a high safety class. In the above calculations, a total structural collapse was assumed in 5% of the allision events.
As reference, KARLA C has a winter displacement of 8,641.40 t with a draught of 6.5 metres.
In the channel of Masnedsund, the current changes regularly depending on the weather conditions and can reach up to 3-4 knots. During periods of adverse weather conditions, the current can have the same direction for several days reaching up to 5 knots. On the day of the accident the current near the bridge was estimated to approx. 2.5 knots.
KARLA C suffered considerable damage to the hull on the port quarter, the gangway and the life boat davit. Furthermore, the port side fresh water tank was penetrated and was nearly emptied.
The bridge was struck on the western side where the footpath and road were situated. The railway was on the eastern side. There was damage to the duc d’alpe west of the centre pillar and the bridge construction including the footpath, light mast, bridge support structure and railway.
KARLA C was one of ten sister ships within the company and it was tramp trading primarily in Northern Europe and the Mediterranean carrying break bulk and regular bulk such as steel and grain. Neither the ship nor the master had called at the Port of Vordingborg before, but this was not considered a significant challenge, because the ship tended to call at smaller ports of a similar size in channels and rivers that are less accessible for other larger ships.
The Masnedsund Bridge that connects the islands of Zealand and Masnedø was built in 1937, is 215 metres long and has a width of 8.8 metres. It is a combined bascule bridge with a single-track railway and a road. It has five supporting pillars and a height between 4 and 5 metres from the water surface to the spans.
On the seabed on the western side of the bridge where the port is situated there are power cables and pipelines for sewage, gas and district heating.
The bridge is usually manned daily, except during the hours of the night unless otherwise agreed with a ship requesting a scheduled passing. Approximately 2,000 ships of varying sizes pass the bridge annually.
In 2002, a risk analysis was made of the scenarios in which a ship might allide with the bridge pillars and/or the steel structure. The analysis concluded that the bascule supporting pillars should be able to withstand the impact of a ship with a range of displacement of 6,400-7,800 t if the bridge pillars were to be considered as belonging in a high safety class. Furthermore, the steel beams between the pillars should be able to withstand the impact of a ship with a range of displacement of 1,500-4,700 t if the steel beams were to be considered as belonging in a high safety class. In the above calculations, a total structural collapse was assumed in 5% of the allision events.
As reference, KARLA C has a winter displacement of 8,641.40 t with a draught of 6.5 metres.
In the channel of Masnedsund, the current changes regularly depending on the weather conditions and can reach up to 3-4 knots. During periods of adverse weather conditions, the current can have the same direction for several days reaching up to 5 knots. On the day of the accident the current near the bridge was estimated to approx. 2.5 knots.
KARLA C suffered considerable damage to the hull on the port quarter, the gangway and the life boat davit. Furthermore, the port side fresh water tank was penetrated and was nearly emptied.
The bridge was struck on the western side where the footpath and road were situated. The railway was on the eastern side. There was damage to the duc d’alpe west of the centre pillar and the bridge construction including the footpath, light mast, bridge support structure and railway.