|
News Code
121741
Copied
Clouds could be leaving the Medium - Range(MR) Tankers’ Horizon
TIN news: Most product tanker delegates seem to be in agreement that the market has had its share of rough patch since the start of 2016. Things have been rather difficult in the Medium-Range (MR) product tanker segment, i.e. ships of between 25,000 to 55,000 dwt, where TCE earnings across a number of key routes have frequently flirted with the operational breakeven, although the winter season has brought with it some temporary relief. In its latest weekly report, shipbroker Gibson noted that “the factors behind the weak market are known. On one hand, we are seeing continued strong increases in supply across all product tanker sizes and cannibalisation between them. On the other hand, demand continues to suffer from swollen land based stocks, accumulated since 2015. Although overall global inventories have started to dip in recent months, some areas remain heavily oversupplied, limiting trade and arbitrage opportunities”.
“So when the tide turns in the owners’ favour? On the macro level, much will depend on demand factors, such as growth in product consumption, the level of stocks, refining developments and regional product imbalances. Although global oil demand is expected to continue to grow, elevated inventories and delays to start-ups of new export orientated refining projects, particularly those in the Middle East – all suggest that the major uplift in the product tanker demand is not quite on the cards yet”, Gibson said.
The London-based shipbroker went on to note that “however, aside from demand, we also have supply side developments which are starting to look a little bit more encouraging, at least for MRs. A multiyear period of intense deliveries is drawing to a close. Limited investment in new tonnage between 2014 and 2016 means that the MR orderbook now is at its lowest level at least since 2005 – at just 6.5% relative to its current size, with existing orders almost entirely in the larger 40,000 to 55,000 dwt segment. The vast majority of these units are scheduled for delivery over the next 18 months, translating into a much lower delivery profile relative to what the market has witnessed in recent years”.
“At the same time, prospects for tanker demolition are also improving. In the near term, scrapping activity will remain primarily driven by earnings at the time and as such a prolonged period of weak market conditions could facilitate demolition activity. Furthermore, around 6% of the trading MR fleet is over 20 years of age and these units are now more vulnerable to near term scrapping than ever before. This is due to the Ballast Water Management (BWM) convention which will come into force in September this year. Certainly, these aging ladies are highly unlikely to install a BWM system so late in their trading life; while the economics of de-coupling the renewal of the IOPP certificate from dry docking to delay BWM installation are questionable”, Gibson noted.

It added that “the analysis of deliveries, the age profile and factors affecting demolition all suggest the potential for flattening MR supply over the next 18-24 months, which will improve the supply/demand balance. The expectation of continued growth in larger product tankers over the same period (due to a later surge in ordering activity) could offset these developments. However, competition from the larger sizes may have a limited effect due to port restrictions on some key trades in the Mediterranean, Baltic and the UK Continent, one of the primary markets for smaller MR tonnage. A word of caution…Newbuild prices have fallen to their lowest level since 2004, the orderbook is minimal and there is strong potential for major increases in demolition post 2020 due to the combined effect of the BWM legislation and IMO global sulphur limits, all this offers an attractive investment proposition in new tonnage. As such, we could see an increase in speculative and counter-cyclical ordering, which if “overcooked”, could lead to another period of strong growth in MR supply in the medium term”, Gibson concluded.
Meanwhile, in the MR product tanker segment this past week, Gibson noted that “sporadic fixing in the Continent shows a market holding value between deals as intermittent positioning of natural tonnage creates an underlying strength Charterers cannot avoid. Fixing ahead in this market has proved a wise option as come Friday some Charterers are left considering coverage on alternative sizes. In the Mediterranean those Owners who opted to move on part cargoes immediately upon this week’s opening may have just performed a chartering masterstroke! As with such limited natural sized enquiry and the Handies shedding value where the week progressed, those early deals now look rather good. This said, with this week concluded, however, and levels being corrected down, it is looking more probable that a floor has been found”, the shipbroker concluded.
“So when the tide turns in the owners’ favour? On the macro level, much will depend on demand factors, such as growth in product consumption, the level of stocks, refining developments and regional product imbalances. Although global oil demand is expected to continue to grow, elevated inventories and delays to start-ups of new export orientated refining projects, particularly those in the Middle East – all suggest that the major uplift in the product tanker demand is not quite on the cards yet”, Gibson said.
The London-based shipbroker went on to note that “however, aside from demand, we also have supply side developments which are starting to look a little bit more encouraging, at least for MRs. A multiyear period of intense deliveries is drawing to a close. Limited investment in new tonnage between 2014 and 2016 means that the MR orderbook now is at its lowest level at least since 2005 – at just 6.5% relative to its current size, with existing orders almost entirely in the larger 40,000 to 55,000 dwt segment. The vast majority of these units are scheduled for delivery over the next 18 months, translating into a much lower delivery profile relative to what the market has witnessed in recent years”.
“At the same time, prospects for tanker demolition are also improving. In the near term, scrapping activity will remain primarily driven by earnings at the time and as such a prolonged period of weak market conditions could facilitate demolition activity. Furthermore, around 6% of the trading MR fleet is over 20 years of age and these units are now more vulnerable to near term scrapping than ever before. This is due to the Ballast Water Management (BWM) convention which will come into force in September this year. Certainly, these aging ladies are highly unlikely to install a BWM system so late in their trading life; while the economics of de-coupling the renewal of the IOPP certificate from dry docking to delay BWM installation are questionable”, Gibson noted.
It added that “the analysis of deliveries, the age profile and factors affecting demolition all suggest the potential for flattening MR supply over the next 18-24 months, which will improve the supply/demand balance. The expectation of continued growth in larger product tankers over the same period (due to a later surge in ordering activity) could offset these developments. However, competition from the larger sizes may have a limited effect due to port restrictions on some key trades in the Mediterranean, Baltic and the UK Continent, one of the primary markets for smaller MR tonnage. A word of caution…Newbuild prices have fallen to their lowest level since 2004, the orderbook is minimal and there is strong potential for major increases in demolition post 2020 due to the combined effect of the BWM legislation and IMO global sulphur limits, all this offers an attractive investment proposition in new tonnage. As such, we could see an increase in speculative and counter-cyclical ordering, which if “overcooked”, could lead to another period of strong growth in MR supply in the medium term”, Gibson concluded.
Meanwhile, in the MR product tanker segment this past week, Gibson noted that “sporadic fixing in the Continent shows a market holding value between deals as intermittent positioning of natural tonnage creates an underlying strength Charterers cannot avoid. Fixing ahead in this market has proved a wise option as come Friday some Charterers are left considering coverage on alternative sizes. In the Mediterranean those Owners who opted to move on part cargoes immediately upon this week’s opening may have just performed a chartering masterstroke! As with such limited natural sized enquiry and the Handies shedding value where the week progressed, those early deals now look rather good. This said, with this week concluded, however, and levels being corrected down, it is looking more probable that a floor has been found”, the shipbroker concluded.