|
News Code
107453
Copied
Hutchinson Port Holdings Results’ Review: Dividend buoys interest, but not for long
TIN news: Results in line with expectation: Hutchison Port Holdings Trust (HPHT) reported a weak set of 3Q16 earnings that are broadly within our expectations. Revenue contracted 6.8% y/y from HKD3,502m to HKD3,265m, as consolidated throughput shrank 6.7% y/y from 5.7m teu to 5.3m teu in the three months through September. Similar to the previous quarters, throughput growth in Hong Kong was the main laggard. Despite inorganic boost in earnings from rent, government rebates and preferential tax treatment, PATMI plunged 18.2% y/y to HKD 430m in 3Q16, against HKD 526m in the same period last year. Even without a conservative change in the equipment’s useful life estimates, PATMI would have been 17.2% y/y below last year’s. The Trust made a provision for receivables subsequent to Hanjin’s bankruptcy, squeezing the operating margin from 43.1% to 42.3%. However, the company’s EBITDA margin held up well on shedding transhipment cargoes that had thinner profits than gateway
cargoes. The latest 9M16 results formed 75% and 88% of our full-year revenue and PATMI projections, respectively.
Port competition for transhipment volumes: HPHT’s poor quarterly result was attributed to decreased empty and transhipment containers in the past three months. We believe volumes have been moving from ports in Hong Kong and East Shenzhen to neighbouring ports of Guangzhou-Nansha and Shenzhen Chiwan. China Merchants Port Holdings at Shenzhen Chiwan reported throughput increase in 3Q16, while port volumes at Guangzhou-Nansha surged 9.5% y/y in July and August 2016 (data for September unavailable). While HPHT’s average revenue yield per teu changed marginally in the quarter, the spare capacity from soft transhipment volumes meant that inflation in costs would cut deeper on profits. Structural decline in Hong Kong’s transhipment volume is likely to continue, while Yantian offers a glimmer of hope as local authorities have been promoting trade in the city’s eastern zone.
Gearing climbs, DPU under threat: HPHT is one of the highest-geared companies among the Chinese port operators under our coverage. The latest management outlook overlooks the need to deleverage. The net gearing of the company rose from 42% in FY15 to 45% in 9M16, following a distribution of HKD 1,220m, or (HKD 0.14 per unit), to shareholders. Maintaining the current pace of distribution would see net gearing of HPHT hitting 48% by year-end, when its peers CMPH and China Cosco Ports have projected gearing of under 30%. We expect HKD 0.12 for the second semi-annual payment. Our distribution per unit (DPU) forecast -represents a yield of 7.5%- does not derail the investment merit of HPHT being one of the highest-yielding companies on the Singapore Stock Exchange. Throughput growth is unlikely to gain traction in 2017 and 2018 on overcapacity concerns in the Pearl River Delta region. Against the backdrop, we believe DPU will slide lower next year as management has placed emphasis on debt management in 2018.
Value and Risk: We maintain our DCF-derived fair value of USD 0.44, translating to a demanding 20.3x/23.2x FY16e/FY17e PE, compared with our basket of terminal operators trading at average PEs of 18.4x/17.6x. Start-up costs on the additional capacity at Yantian are likely to hit bottom line in the next two years, further undermining HPHT’s ability to sustain the dividend yield. According to our bespoke DMER ranking methodology, HPHT scores Orange for both valuation and risk.
Port competition for transhipment volumes: HPHT’s poor quarterly result was attributed to decreased empty and transhipment containers in the past three months. We believe volumes have been moving from ports in Hong Kong and East Shenzhen to neighbouring ports of Guangzhou-Nansha and Shenzhen Chiwan. China Merchants Port Holdings at Shenzhen Chiwan reported throughput increase in 3Q16, while port volumes at Guangzhou-Nansha surged 9.5% y/y in July and August 2016 (data for September unavailable). While HPHT’s average revenue yield per teu changed marginally in the quarter, the spare capacity from soft transhipment volumes meant that inflation in costs would cut deeper on profits. Structural decline in Hong Kong’s transhipment volume is likely to continue, while Yantian offers a glimmer of hope as local authorities have been promoting trade in the city’s eastern zone.
Gearing climbs, DPU under threat: HPHT is one of the highest-geared companies among the Chinese port operators under our coverage. The latest management outlook overlooks the need to deleverage. The net gearing of the company rose from 42% in FY15 to 45% in 9M16, following a distribution of HKD 1,220m, or (HKD 0.14 per unit), to shareholders. Maintaining the current pace of distribution would see net gearing of HPHT hitting 48% by year-end, when its peers CMPH and China Cosco Ports have projected gearing of under 30%. We expect HKD 0.12 for the second semi-annual payment. Our distribution per unit (DPU) forecast -represents a yield of 7.5%- does not derail the investment merit of HPHT being one of the highest-yielding companies on the Singapore Stock Exchange. Throughput growth is unlikely to gain traction in 2017 and 2018 on overcapacity concerns in the Pearl River Delta region. Against the backdrop, we believe DPU will slide lower next year as management has placed emphasis on debt management in 2018.
Value and Risk: We maintain our DCF-derived fair value of USD 0.44, translating to a demanding 20.3x/23.2x FY16e/FY17e PE, compared with our basket of terminal operators trading at average PEs of 18.4x/17.6x. Start-up costs on the additional capacity at Yantian are likely to hit bottom line in the next two years, further undermining HPHT’s ability to sustain the dividend yield. According to our bespoke DMER ranking methodology, HPHT scores Orange for both valuation and risk.